Gig review: Doves at Rock City, with White Flowers

Words: Lawrence Poole
Photos: Stephanie Webb
Thursday 13 March 2025
reading time: min, words

With frontman Jimi Goodwin only at Rock City 'in spirit' Doves fought on to perform a Nottingham show that proved the relience and quality of their back catalogue...

Doves Stephaniewebb 29A4347

It can be a difficult sell – the Monday night gig. Following a weekend of glorious sunshine where the Brits' default tendency is to overindulge whenever the shorts and T-shirts come out from the back of the drawers, rallying yourself for a night at Rock City requires added impetus.

Sadly, it appears Doves are fighting their own battles too. With frontman Jimi Goodwin currently absent from the touring line-up due to health issues, it is down to guitarist Jez Williams to step up to the plate and take on the lion’s (Doves’?) share of the vocal duties. He, as he quickly confirms, is losing his voice and manfully strains throughout to hit the notes. It doesn’t help that such is the distinctiveness of Goodwin’s Mancunian baritone, there was already apprehension amongst the band’s ardent masses about how things would pan out.

Sensibly, the remaining duo (Williams’ twin Andy is on drums) have bolstered the live line-up with four other musicians to both beef up the sound and split vocal duties to degrees of success.

Doves Stephaniewebb 29A4294
Doves Stephaniewebb 29A4387

What is undeniable is the quality of both their back catalogue and the prime cuts from their latest long-player, the typically grandiose yet soul soothing, Constellations For The Lonely. Nathan Sudders takes over Goodwin’s bass parts admirably while Christian Madden provides the keyboard licks which have bolstered their sound so distinctly for 25 years.

Doves Stephaniewebb 29A4349
The Northern Soul-inspired and magisterial Here It Comes is dedicated to the absent frontman who is ‘here in spirit’ while the gorgeous Snowdon and Winter Hill tip a hat to great therapeutic walking locations of the north west.
   
Throughout, though, there is a nagging feeling that the sound isn’t quite right. The full, bass-driven dynamic which emerged from their 1990s club culture predecessor Sub Sub just doesn’t feel present on their indie club bangers Pounding, Black and White Town and There Goes The Fear, so the night doesn’t quite take off as you expect it would – perhaps the buoyancy provided by a weekend booking would have helped? 
   
What does work much more effectively is their gorgeous, more contemplative moments – Caught By The River and The Cedar Room remain timelessly beautiful, while new track Last Year’s Man holds its own in strong company.

Ironically, by the time they play out with Space Face from their aforementioned Sub Sub days, it is like a switch is flicked and suddenly the fuller sound expected throughout floods deliciously through the venue.

Alas, it feels a bit ‘too little, too late’.

Doves have a much-loved place in so many music fans’ hearts as the plethora of groups of friends who have reunited tonight to relive memories and make new ones attests and you could sense everyone is willing the new ‘live’ Doves to make a success of it. LeftLion hopes that in the meantime they do, and it won’t be too long before Goodwin returns to reinforce the distinctive sound they are so rightly acclaimed for.
Doves performed at Rock City on 10th March 2025. Support came from Preston duo White Flowers (see photo gallery below)
Doves Stephaniewebb 29A4318

White Flowers

We have a favour to ask

LeftLion is Nottingham’s meeting point for information about what’s going on in our city, from the established organisations to the grassroots. We want to keep what we do free to all to access, but increasingly we are relying on revenue from our readers to continue. Can you spare a few quid each month to support us?

Support LeftLion

Sign in using

Or using your

Forgot password?

Register an account

Password must be at least 8 characters long, have 1 uppercase, 1 lowercase, 1 number and 1 special character.

Forgotten your password?

Reset your password?

Password must be at least 8 characters long, have 1 uppercase, 1 lowercase, 1 number and 1 special character.